WHAT’S WRONG WITH THE TRANS MOUNTAIN EXPANSION PIPELINE (TMEP) PROJECT ?

Almost everything…

  1. The shipping terminal (Burnaby) too risky… better locations apparent.
  2. Our  Prime Minister preferred TMEP…without ever  seeking  an independent risk assessment…unforgiveable !
  3. The proposed  tanker routes never  ‘permitted by any southern BC communities’
  4. There is no proven ,’world class’, method to clean up that inevitable diluted bitumen(dilbit) tanker spill.
  5. Any spill containment, recovery will be only partially successful
  6. The NEB hearing process was too restricted and minimized open public debate ,or questioning of proponent’s experts
  7. The Prime Minister’s own counsel ….”governments issue permits, but ONLY communities give permission”…was ignored !
  8. BC established ,multibillion dollar annual, job creating ,environmentally related visitor industries ,could  be damaged , needlessly.
  9. The Prime Minister offered to ‘mediate’ the pipeline issue in BC…maybe he should stay home for a while and get on with mediating ..10.
  10. .An independent expert risk assessment could be directed by the new Chief Science Officer… so  do that —before it’s too late !

Carl Shalansky, P. Eng. (Retired)

Blog: https://redfern3359.wordpress.com/

(604) 986-4657

 

Advertisements

THE ENVIRONMENT WILL PAY

http://www.macleans.ca/economy/a-b-c-pipeline-spill-would-be-inevitable-but-who-would-pay/

Thank you Erik Heinrich and MACLEANS…finally someone has gathered all the pertinent issues and clearly stated the Prime Minister’s chosen   ill-conceived diluted bitumen(dilbit) export scheme. Thank you, thank you !The Kinder Morgan export scheme (Trans Mountain Expansion Pipeline,(TMEP) plan was never subjected to an independent expert risk assessment study comparison, strangely. The southern BC residents have put up a good fight so far…but as ‘father Pierre’ once said….when asked what he planned to do…he said ‘just watch me’ !

The simple truth is that there are many thousands of miles of existing pipelines which function reasonably well…there are likely at least 3 pipelines/conduits  in your street, each capable of causing considerable damage if they are damaged…for whatever reason….and we do not lie awake worrying about such a damaging event…And ‘no’, there is no plan to shut down any pipeline because one pipe might be damaged ,somewhere, sometime… Unless we allow our politicians to be sold a goofy pipeline scheme such the Trans Mountain Expansion Pipeline (TMEP)scheme, as designed by the Kinder Morgan  bean counters.

Yes Justin Trudeau and Christy Clark were playing a pipelines game, always with the next election in mind .Christy Clark lost, Stephen Harper was hurt by his stubborn palling up with the oil patch, Justin is playing chicken as he gambles that the Eastern vote will save his government as he chose to sacrifice a few western seats for the several dozens of seats in the East metropolises ! The Energy East pipeline should have been a slam dunk…more good paying jobs, while curtailing foreign oil imports. An absolutely outrageous ,obviously politically driven BAD decision.

Justin Trudeau once offered to mediate the western pipeline saga. Maybe he should stay home and we’ll happily ‘watch him’ as he mediates the pipeline issue to a common sense conclusion…instead of him travelling the globe to gather more selfies…Our government has a stable of scientists now complemented with the addition of the new Chief Science Officer that could competently direct the preparation of an independent risk assessment to identify the least risky tanker routes on the BC coast…surely not through busy Vancouver Harbour or the island bound international Salish Sea…

To not build Energy East is folly, the least-risk tanker routed BC coastal outlet to Asia is a must, the Keystone XL,we or must still wait the final word from President Trump.…but let’s get on with the doable NOW ! I guess that there are at least two Canadian ‘pipeliners’ who would jump at the chance to build a smarter, much less risky pipeline/shipping infrastructure system !

Erik Heinrich hit the nail on the head when he suggested that there is not enough money allocated for dealing with effectively a major tanker spill…”THE ENVIRONMENT WILL PAY”…Imagine a diluted bitumen (dilbit) laden tanker hung up on  reef, spilling dilbit profusely, at night during a winter storm, while the spill handling crews scramble to the scene…with the still unproven “world class” cleanup contraptions on board !

 

Carl Shalansky, P. Eng. (Retired)

Blog: https://redfern3359.wordpress.com/

(604) 986-4657

North Vancouver,BC

POLITICS RULES—ALWAYS…

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/squamish-nation-taking-fight-against-kinder-morgan-to-court-1.4389746

“The Squamish Nation says it was not given adequate information about the safety risks…associated with Kinder Morgan’s … expansion project.” Ask the newly appointed  government Chief Science Officer(CSO) to direct preparation of an independent risk assessment to locate the ’least risk’ tanker routes !  If the NEB had such an independent  report in hand  they could have  chosen more ‘communities’ permissible’ routes ! …

Best way to save our multibillion dollar annual ,job intensive visitor industry revenues, is to remove those added  tankers from the busy  BC waters !

When the Eastern 120 ridings  squawk a bit  the Liberal government hears …When those 29 western ridings(BC17,Alb 4,Sask/Man 8), ask for action…nothing happens ,yet !

PLAN B DELUXE

http://business.financialpost.com/commodities/energy/no-plan-b-for-liberals-on-pipelines

“No Plan B for Liberals on pipelines

Energy East died Thursday after Ottawa expanded its regulatory review to include climate change impacts of the whole upstream and downstream oil industry”

 

Here’s a Plan B…since our Federal government saw fit to kill  Energy East…why not also shut down the goofier , much disliked, Trans Mountain Expansion Pipeline(TMEP) as proposed. Call for an independent scientific risk assessment study of the BC coast and find the least risky tanker routes….where larger tankers would not sail ,at less risk, in BC environmentally sensitive waters…and give tankers direct access to the open  Pacific. Set up the invitation for export bids to ensure that only competent pipe-liners could apply…and may ‘the best proposal win’ ! This gives the pipe liners an opportunity to recoup some of the costs incurred with their earlier failed bids. Seems fair ? Expect Enbridge, Kinder Morgen and Trans Canada to come up with ,more community acceptable export proposals.

 

ONCE MORE…RELOCATE TANKER ROUTE…

 

Come on…the issue is about the 700% increased diluted bitumen(dilbit) tankers sailings in our busy, environmentally sensitive waters…all unnecessarily ! The entire Kinder Morgan ,Trans Mountain Expansion Pipeline (TMEP) project was a handy ,bean counter designed idea…Sorry guys the BC public has said no ,no, no .In fact we  helped to send two governments to the showers ..remember friend Harper…and  our deaf BC Liberal bunch. Need we try for three ?

Hopefully our court review will order a routing review. Our Canadian Senate recently counselled Government …. When they offered in their  Pipeline Study  the  need to   “…restore legitimacy to the pipeline approval process.” 

Yes, our government believes in the value of science BEFORE  deciding , a belief recently reinforced as they announced the appointment of their Chief Science Officer(CSO)…who could likely convince  our Prime Minister that HIS long standing PREFERENCE for the TMEP is a mistake…which the BC public want   corrected…before it’s too late . The CSO ,as her first challenge, and with an independent risk assessment , COULD  demonstrate where less risky tanker routes exist along our coast.

Carl Shalansky, P. Eng. (Retired)

Blog: https://redfern3359.wordpress.com/

(604) 986-4657

 

FINALLY,A SCIENCE DEVELOPED ROUTE…!finally…

Could the Prime Minister  be  looking for a pipeline/tanker route plan to  which “communities could give permission” and  a plan that supports his government latest  claim  … “We need to be basing our decisions… on SCIENCE !

Fortunately this announced science interest  could give the PM the answer to this delayed ,vital ,diluted bitumen (dilbit) export plan…Could  the waiting BC/Washington State public interference  cause Kinder Morgan to ‘pack up’ and leave ….causing us we find another  pipe-liner to assist with export of Alberta dilbit.

As noted in an online report  ‘the NEB … would hold a series of public hearings …to determine the ROUTE for …TMEP….Could the NEB could force Kinder Morgan to change its route….!

Here’s an opportunity to produce an independent risk assessment that identifies the least risky tanker routes in BC waters…Let the new Chief Science Officer , along with the NEB’ Chief Environmental Officer guide our government through  to an independent scientific risk  decision and determine where to build our dilbit export infrastructure … with  NO POLITICS !

DON’T MESS WITH BC VOTERS….

Did  the Trans Mountain Expansion Pipeline (TMEP)project cause the BC Liberals to pay the ultimate political price  ? The Liberals chose NOT TO LISTEN and lost key southern BC ridings…Now Premier elect Horgan gives fuzzy signals about TMEP…or will he and Weaver ‘figure it out ‘,and pave the way for the next election ,by supporting this economically vital export plan. Harper’s gone(remember him).Must we wait until Oct 2019 for the next ‘victim ‘ …or will PM Trudeau alter  his maddening decision to approve the ill-conceived TMEP ?!

The issue of  concern always has been about that inevitable diluted bitumen (dilbit) spill as tanker traffic is increased 7 fold   …thus  greatly increasing probability of significant adverse impact on our multibillion dollar visitor ,environmentally related,job creating, ‘visitor’ industries !

 

An  opportunity still exists to earn those vital export revenues ….for all  Canadians …simply by locating the dilbit shipping terminal where departing tankers would have open  access to the Pacific.

Simple as that !

BC PUBLIC WILL DECIDE….

 

 

 

Have the governments not noticed…how an  angry BC public ,utilized  the ultimate hearing process ,the  ballot box…and  contributed to ‘taking down’ 2 governments….and now wait for Oct 2019…

 

 

Stephen  Harper Federal   government goes down !

 

The  Trudeau cohort ,Christy Clark, ‘liked’ the ill-conceived  Trans Mountain Expansion Pipeline (TMEP)  …. Public  concern remains  about the inevitable diluted bitumen (dilbit) leak from the greatly increased number of tankers in our busy waters..  Trudeau Government  approved ,the goofy TMEP …with no independent ,science based risk assessment .

Christy Clark BC Provincial government  goes  down !

 

Revenue generating , pipelines are vital for Canada’s economy…A solution stares us in the face ,that reduces probability a tanker sourced dilbit leak from  a tanker . Build one smarter pipeline ,from Alberta to BC coast terminal, that offers tankers direct access to the open Pacific…

 

 

Carl Shalansky, P. Eng. (Retired)

Blog: https://redfern3359.wordpress.com/

(604) 986-4657

SMARTER WAYS….

 

There are smarter ways to export this without the proposed  7 fold increase of diluted bitumen (dilbit)tankers cruising our busy Vancouver B.C. harbour , and the island bound ,Canada/US shared ,Salish Sea  .

Canada too has a history of standing against disrespectful behavior of industry…our infamous War in the Woods episode , (Clayoquot sound near Tofino to oppose the clearcutting of an old growth forest) …………might be seen ,again, if TMEP proceed with this ill-conceived pipeline project.

 

Washington State has produced a comprehensive risk assessment study about shipping, in of our shared Salish Sea …and they are not happy…

Canada could export dilbit through one pipeline that loads tankers in an area far from busy ,environmentally, less risk-prone route…near Port Simpson BC…that offers tankers access to the open Pacific and  likely greatly lessens the probability of an diluted bitumen spill in Canadian/US busy ,island-bound waters…but, let independent risk assessment science be done ,first !

Our government , has chosen to ignore BC public outcry against the TMEP as proposed…

Maybe our Washington State neighbours could call our BC Premier Clark Prime Minster ..or ask President Trump to call neighbour  Prime Minister  Trudeau   and work out a more mutually acceptable deal…and forgo potential of another  Standing Rock Sioux situation or War in the Woods like incident.

Carl Shalansky, P. Eng. (Retired)

Blog: https://redfern3359.wordpress.com/

(604) 986-4657

North Vancouver ,BC

COULDA,SHOULDA,WOULDA

Had the Enbridge Board listened to their new Enbridge President and C.E.O.,AL Monaco ,who hinted to the media, that the Enbridge Natural Gas Pipeline(NGP) , ‘possibly’ could be moved out of Douglas Channel,….. NGP might have been built by now !!

Enbridge and Kinder Morgan leaders likely relied on PM Harper’s ‘signal’ that he could whisk these vital pipeline projects through Parliament…?
Now a jinx appeared… a new Prime Minister,(who promised to use science …but soon forgot) … suddenly made a ‘knee jerk’ decision to ban oil tanker traffic from the BC north Coast… and then with similar’ knee jerk’ precision, APPROVED the ill-conceived Trans Mountain Expansion Pipeline…!

Mr. Monaco’s recent comment to oil biggies , that it’s …‘about actually LISTENING…and RESPONDNING ‘… should give us some hope…
Our Senate has just released THEIR ‘critical’ pipelines report…where they made recommendations on how the government can restore legitimacy to the pipeline approval process !
Imagine this scenario ,where our much impugned Senate rejects government’s hastily decided, unscientifically proven, pipeline decisions… …and instructs Government to find the ‘least- risk’ marine ROUTE AND avoid needless tanker travel through busy, or island bound waters…
Build ONE PIPELINE SYSTEM, to an open water location near Port Simpson …and celebrate a science based decision…that would REMOVE the 7 fold increase of dilbit laden tankers in the busy, island bound waters…and gain those much needed export revenues !

.
Carl Shalansky,P Eng ,retired
https://redfern3359.wordpress.com
North Vancouver,
604 986 4657